How do religious leaders in Pakistan view second marriages?

This article explores the perspectives of religious leaders in Pakistan, their views on polygamy, and how they address social, legal, and ethical concerns surrounding second marriages.

1. The Islamic Basis for Second Marriages

Islamic teachings on second marriages (polygamy) come primarily from the Qur'an and Hadith.

A. Qur’anic Guidelines on Polygamy

The Qur'an allows a man to marry up to four wives, but only under strict conditions:

"If you fear that you will not be just with the orphan girls, then marry those that please you of women, two, three, or four. But if you fear that you will not be just, then [marry] only one…" (Surah An-Nisa 4:3)

The verse emphasizes justice and fairness in multiple marriages, and if a man cannot maintain fairness, he is advised to marry only one wife.

B. The Prophet’s (PBUH) Example

The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) had multiple wives, but his marriages were based on:

✅ Compassion – Many wives were widows or divorcees in need of support.

✅ Justice & Fairness – He treated all wives with equality in time, resources, and emotions.

Islamic teachings do not make second marriages obligatory, but they allow them under specific conditions.

2. Religious Leaders’ Views on Second Marriages in Pakistan

Religious scholars in Pakistan generally fall into three broad categories regarding second marriages:

A. Traditionalist Scholars – Strongly Supportive of Second Marriages

Many conservative Islamic scholars strongly endorse polygamy as a legitimate Islamic practice. Their key arguments include:

✅ Polygamy is a Divine Right – Since Islam permits it, no law should restrict it.

✅ Prevention of Immorality – If a man desires another relationship, it is better for him to marry rather than engage in sinful acts.

✅ Providing Shelter to Widows & Divorcees – Scholars argue that second marriages help support women in need.

✅ Population Growth & Family Strength – Some scholars believe polygamy contributes to stronger Muslim families.

These scholars oppose laws like the Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961, which require first-wife permission before a second marriage.

B. Moderate Scholars – Conditional Support Based on Justice & Ethics

Some scholars believe that while Islam permits second marriages, they must be just, responsible, and legally compliant. Their views include:

✅ Polygamy should be a rare exception, not a norm – Islam allows polygamy but discourages it if justice is not possible.

✅ Fairness is a strict condition – They highlight Qur’an 4:129, which states that "You will never be able to do justice between wives, even if you strive to do so."

✅ Legal Compliance is Necessary – Since Pakistani law requires permission from the first wife, Muslims should respect legal regulations.

✅ Economic Stability Matters – A man should only take a second wife if he can financially support both families fairly.

These scholars believe misuse of polygamy causes harm and contradicts the spirit of Islamic justice.

C. Reformist Scholars – Critical of Second Marriages Without Just Cause

Some religious scholars and Islamic feminists argue that:

❌ Polygamy is often misused – Many men take second wives irresponsibly, leading to neglect and injustice.

❌ Women’s Rights Are Ignored – The first wife and children often suffer emotionally and financially.

❌ Islam Prefers Monogamy – Reformist scholars highlight that justice in polygamy is nearly impossible, so monogamy is preferred.

❌ Secret Marriages are Unethical – Many men hide their second marriages, which is both un-Islamic and illegal.

These scholars believe that second marriages should only be allowed in exceptional circumstances, such as:

If the first wife is chronically ill or unable to conceive.
If the second marriage provides protection to a widow or divorcee.

Many reformist scholars support Pakistan’s legal restrictions on polygamy to prevent exploitation.

3. Challenges & Misuse of Second Marriages in Pakistan

While religious leaders provide guidance, second marriages in Pakistan often face serious challenges:

A. Secret Marriages & Legal Violations

Many men:

❌ Hide their second marriages from their first wives.

❌ Ignore legal requirements, violating Pakistani law.

❌ Fail to financially support both families fairly.

Religious scholars criticize this misuse and emphasize accountability in polygamy.

B. First Wives Facing Injustice

Many first wives experience emotional distress and family disputes.
Islamic scholars stress that polygamy must not cause oppression, but in reality, many women suffer neglect.

C. Children & Inheritance Disputes

Children from different marriages often face conflicts over inheritance.
Islam requires fair inheritance laws, but family disputes remain common.

4. Role of Religious Leaders in Addressing Second Marriage Issues

Religious leaders in Pakistan can play a vital role in ensuring that second marriages are conducted ethically.

A. Educating Men About Responsibilities

Ulema should emphasize justice, fairness, and financial responsibility.
Many men believe polygamy is their right, without understanding the strict Islamic conditions.

B. Supporting Women’s Rights

Religious leaders should promote women’s right to divorce (Khula) if they face injustice.
Encourage society to respect widows’ and divorcees’ remarriage rights.

C. Advocating for Ethical Polygamy Practices

Ensure second marriages are public and transparent (not secretive).
Educate families about Islamic principles of justice in polygamy.

5. Conclusion: A Balanced Islamic Approach to Second Marriages

The views of religious Permission for Second Marriage in Lahore leaders in Pakistan vary widely, from strong support to conditional approval and even criticism of second marriages.

Key Takeaways:

✅ Traditionalist scholars fully support polygamy, seeing it as a divine right.

✅ Moderate scholars believe second marriages should follow Islamic justice and legal requirements.

✅ Reformist scholars argue that polygamy is often misused and harmful to women.

✅ Islam requires fairness, and if justice cannot be maintained, monogamy is preferred.

✅ Religious leaders must educate men about responsible and ethical second marriages.The esteemed team of expert lawyers at Khadija Law Associates excels in providing exceptional legal services to clients dealing with family disputes.

Ultimately, second marriages in Pakistan should align with both Islamic teachings and ethical justice, ensuring fairness, transparency, and the protection of women's rights.

Search This Blog

Permission of Second Marriage